Rotolo's Pizzeria - Fairhope, AL

Amanda Koehler

My 8yr old son and I had lunch today and we LOVE this place. 1st of all the atmosphere was top knotch! Love the brickwork inside! We had a personal cheese pizza and the garlic bread bites! My son said "5 STARS MOM!" Jewels was our server and she was amazing!

There is TONS of seating in different areas. There are many big screen TVs showing sports and news. The back area is the arcade! For $5 we played air hockey, a driving game and the punch bag! My son had a blast! He visited the restroom before we left and told me it was very clean!

Deianaria Brown

This was my first time in there. The food didn’t have much flavor and didn’t expect it to come in such a small dish. There was no manager there. It took about 5 minutes for the server to come greet us. We ordered an appetizer they came out 2 minutes before our food. Our server only came by once or twice. We saw the bartender more than our server. Asked the bartender tender if she could get our check so we could go.

Garlic bites were good

Patti Pinkerton

This was the strangest and worst experience I have had in a restaurant ever. We came in to play trivia and have dinner. The hostess sat us at a table and very quickly a waitress came and took our drink order and in a couple of minutes another young man came and tried to take our drink order again and we explained someone else already took the order and the waitress walked up with the drinks set them down and turned to talk to the waiter. The place was pretty empty, but we waited fifteen minutes and still had not seen our waitress again. I finally got up to look for someone to take our order and found the original waitress who looked up and said oh I never came back "My Bad". She came and took our order right away. We ordered and my husband ordered a Calzone with Salami inside it and it came with something we both thought was ham, the cook came out and assured us that it was Salami. He said they ran out of their regular Salami and were using a replacement. I have had Salami and Ham my whole life and I am sure that wasn't Salami. He was very nice and offered to take it off the ticket and get him something else. By this time my husband was over the whole thing and said no thank he was good. We shared my dinner which wasn't very goo and kept playing Trivia. About 10 minutes later a different girl came and left the bill, this is about an hour before Trivia was over so that was strange since we may have ordered a cocktail or something else. I asked her why she brought the bill so early and she then explained to me how I should leave money or a card with the bill and the waitress would be by to pick it up. I know how to pay a bill in a restaurant, I just was confused why they would close it out an hour before Trivia was over. These places have trivia to bring people in to spend money so that was weird. I then left a card and the same girl, not the waitress came and picked it up. She brought it back and left it on the table with the original receipt with nothing for me to sign. Again, confused we continued to play trivia and in between question went to find someone to explain why there was nothing to sign. Soon the original waitress brought the bill for signature and said they didn't know what happened to it and they had to re-print it. We still tipped 20%, why I don't know but we did. There was a dirty napkin on the floor next to the booth we were in when we were seated and it was still there when we left. We won trivia and gave away the $15 in coupons for this place because I can't imagine going back.

Dakota Conway

Went for Rock N Roll bingo and the red-peeling-faced server was very rude to us when I told her my party was splitting the bill. She never asked if we were all on one ticket. Then, someone in my party wanted to use a coupon, and she responded, "Seriously?" As soon as we sat down, she had thrown our menus down and then she never really checked on us for the rest of the night.

Then, I went later to redeem my free dessert calzone for my birthday, and they said they didn't have one that month; however, if you pull up the menu online, it shows the smores calzone. Why give a free dessert calzone to people for their birthday if they don't always have one? Also, same rude later sent me to someone else when I tried to order even though the sign says go to the end of the bar for to-go orders.

Rita P

Food was very Fresh, if you want a crisp to your wings ask for them to be. Well done. Overall great food and cook. He personally brought our pizza out for us.

Edit: visit in Aug 7:30pm. Waited 15 mins before a waitress came to our table. Ordered chicken Alfredo. Seen in the 3rd pic. It was cold when brought to the table. asked for a new Alfredo and was brought the same dish that had been microwave. As seen in the 2nd pic. The chicken was so overcooked (1st pic) i just decided to just take it out. Overall experience. HORRIBLE. Would not recommend after lunch hours.

Amber Fischer

Excellent food and atmosphere! I have the chalmette cheese sticks ( which is actually like a thin crust pizza! Super yummy. Jake was our server and he was very helpful and I ew the menu. The bacon Mac and cheese was perfect and comes with 4 parmesan garlic knots. My husband got the whole muffaletta which was huge! Don't judge the wings by the picture because they were too die for! Just excellent!

Wendy McElroy

We had a great lunch, and our server was very attentive and nice! See you again soon!

Frankie Price

I wish we had taken photos of our food. We ordered take out 8/30/24 around 7pm. The large supreme pizza appearance was highly substandard. It looked like the pizza was prepared/cooked as a meat pizza and veggies thrown on after the pizza was cooked. The pizza was ready when arrived but the Philly cheesesteak sandwich had not been started. It took an additional 20 minutes to receive the sandwich. The sandwich was very poor in appearance as well. It was very dry. Cheese only on one side of the sandwich. Come on guys! This was horrible. Owner, i wish you would’ve been served this meal. These products should’ve never been presented to the customer. Lesson learned.